The socialist worldview

published 24 Jan 2014
USSR propaganda

I previously published a piece which looked at the political left from an anthropological and external point of view, this article takes a theoretical, internal view of the left.

When people have basic differences in the internal model that they use to navigate the world around them their behaviours and opinions can easily seem irrational and senseless to one another. Understanding somebody’s basic world-view is necessary in order to make any sense of their behaviour: at some level all belief systems that humans adhere to are rational and understandable. When people act in ways that appear strange, it is almost always possible to trace it back to a basic difference in assumptions about how the world works – fundamental differences in internal conceptual models. Before one can make any sense of the internal world of the left, it is necessary to understand their basic shared world-view and how it differs from the more common liberal-democratic model of society.

What distinguishes socialists from the mainstream of the population, more than anything else, is a shared model of the world that differs markedly from the model that is prevalent amongst the general public. Most people do not carry around explicit models in their heads.  They have fuzzy worldviews that are inferred from cultural participation and can include contradictory factors. However, it is easy to identify a common model that underpins most political commentary in the Western world today. Modern states are modelled as democracies which translate popular opinion, with varying degrees of imperfectness, into policy. The state provides public services and regulates the free market system which rewards economic initiative and productivity. Corruption and the repressive, venal and authoritarian nature of political and economic leaders are the principle sources of imperfection which cause real world societies to diverge from the ideal democratic model. Progress towards better societies can be achieved by progressively overcoming these imperfections: by ousting tyrants, jailing corrupt leaders and building better democratic institutions. This model is so pervasive that it is implicit in the great majority of discussion of all political and economic issues throughout the Western media.

Socialists use a quite different basic model of the world which dates back to 1848 and Marx and Engels’s Communist Manifesto. It models societies not as democracies, but as a set of distinct classes with conflicting economic interests. On one side there are the owners of capital – the bourgeoisie; on the other side stand the workers - the proletariat. The conflict of interests between these classes is a structural feature of the economy and will always reassert itself: a never-ending class-struggle which drives social evolution. In this model both the world of private business and the state are considered to be instruments of the bourgeoisie (as the Communist Manifesto puts it: “The executive of the modern state is nothing but a committee for managing the common affairs of the whole bourgeoisie”). On the proletarian side of the divide there is the workers movement – consisting of trade unions, socialist political parties and so on. Progress towards a better society is made by participating in the class struggle on behalf of the proletariat.  There is a intermediate area between the classes - occupied by small business owners (the petite bourgeois) and by managerial workers, however they were considered largely irrelevant to the overall dynamics - it was assumed that they were few in number and weak and would join either the proletariat or the bourgeoisie in times of class conflict. 

The basic shape of the class model is more or less shared by every faction of the historical socialist movement. Although it is very simple, it has enough detail to generate all of the great theoretical cleavages that the socialist movement has experienced since 1848. Most of these can be boiled down to the question of where exactly things should be placed on the model - or in the jargon of socialism, what their “class nature” is. So, the deepest and longest running dispute on the left, between the social democrats, the revolutionary Marxists and the anarchists, relates to the class nature of the state. All of them agree, following Marx, that the state is a bourgeois institution, which serves to enforce the rule of the capitalists. However, it is on the question of whether the state can be moved from its current class position where the trouble arises.

Thee paths to socialism Social Democracy, Revolutionary Marxism, Anarchism image: chekov

The social democrats favour a strategy of attrition where political power is gained through elections and legislative reforms gradually move the state from the bourgeois side of the model to the intermediate area in the middle and finally, one day, to the proletarian side, where it can help usher in socialism. The revolutionary Marxists contend that, although socialists may be able to capture power in parliament, the state is made up of many permanent bodies: the army, the police and the civil service, which will conspire against any elected socialist government to preserve the state’s bourgeois nature. Therefore, state power must be seized through a revolution which will move it almost instantly onto the proletarian side, where it can be used to crush the remnants of the bourgeoisie. The anarchists, for their part, believe that the state is entirely defined by its class nature: it is an instrument of class domination and nothing else. It cannot be reformed or seized, it must be destroyed and replaced with institutions created from the bottom up by the workers.

The class nature of the USSR

With the rise of socialist states in the 20th century, theoretical debate on the far left was dominated by the analysis of the class nature of the Soviet Union and its various satellite states. Where should the Bolshevik state be positioned? The communist parties (or Team USSR as I call them) considered it to be thoroughly proletarian, if flawed, and that it had achieved the elimination of bourgeois power in Russia. The major socialist theoretical opposition came from Leon Trotsky and the Trotskyist parties which he inspired. Trotsky himself considered the Soviet Union to be a ‘degenerated workers state’. Although the state had become corrupted by Stalin’s bureaucracy, the economy still belonged on the proletarian side of the divide - all that was needed was a purge of Stalin's bureaucracy to restore the worker's state. However, many of his followers disagreed. The theory of bureaucratic collectivism, promoted most notably by Max Shachtman and his followers, saw the USSR as occupying the intermediate zone, being neither socialist nor capitalist, with the bureaucracy, or nomenklatura, replacing the bourgeoisie as the exploiter class. Finally, Tony Cliff, the founder of the UK Socialist Workers Party, placed the Russian state and economy squarely on the exploiters' side of the line in his theory of state capitalism, with the system being merely a variation on capitalism with the same class-dynamics and exploitative relations.  There were many other variations on these analyses, of course, but those three had the greatest impact in real-world politics. 

The class nature of the soviet union Three divisive theories - degenerated workers state, bureaucratic collectivism, state capitalism image: chekov

Although these theoretical disputes may appear academic and inconsequential in themselves, they had great practical implications for the participants – because if an entity belonged on the proletarian side of the line, it was a socialist’s duty to defend it, regardless of what criticisms he might have. Conversely, entities on the bourgeois side of the line were the enemy. So, for example, if a party held the orthodox Trotskyist position that North Korea was a degenerated workers state - on the proletarian side of the line - the party’s members might find themselves holding placards on the streets with slogans that called for defence of North Korea’s nuclear program. Those people are not insane – their weird behaviour is a result of a specific feature of their theoretical model of the world.

Not actually insane - the consequences of the degenerated workers state theory image: unknown

Despite the voluminous texts in which these theories were expounded in excruciating detail, it is easy to see the pragmatic considerations that drove their development. Trotsky considered himself to be essentially the leader in exile of the USSR. He was not going to advocate anything that helped their international enemies – his beef was purely with the resident leadership, hence the degenerated workers state theory. Bureaucratic collectivism, for its part, was a theory that made it much easier to operate in the USA and other NATO countries since it did not traitorously take the side of the USSR in the cold-war.  State capitalism, was a theory which allowed far-left political groups to occupy a niche that was neither pro-USSR nor pro-capitalist. In the period between Kruschev’s famous 1956 speech, which denounced Stalin’s crimes, and the protest movements of the late 1960’s, the environment was fertile for a "neither Moscow nor Washington" position. Sure enough, the Team USSR parties shed many members to the upstart state capitalists through that period.

Once the practices that pragmatism demanded had been translated into weighty theoretical form, the theories took on a life of their own, being applied even in situations where they made no sense at all. For example, in Ireland in 1999, the Socialist Workers Party wrote to the Socialist party, both Trotskyist parties, seeking an electoral alliance. The Socialist Party party declined the offer in a pamphlet length letter, 6,000 words of which were dedicated to a critique of the SWP’s theory of state capitalism in comparison to the SP’s degenerated workers state theory. This was a decade after the fall of the Berlin wall and the disappearance of the USSR!

The Class Model of Society Examined

It is easy to pick holes in the basic socialist class-model of society and many have enthusiastically done so. It purports to be a model that describes fundamental social dynamics (“the history of all hitherto existing society is the history of class struggles” - the first line of chapter 1 of the communist manifesto) yet it is based purely on an economic relationship and does not include any cultural factors. It lumps the population into 2 or 3 great undifferentiated masses and assumes that economic forces will tend to push them together into groups with identical economic interests. It makes no allowances for conflict between societies: Marx assumed that the national divisions within classes would eventually dissolve as capitalism spread around the world.The analytic method of deriving an entity’s position in the class model – and whether it should be supported – by deducing its class nature from abstract first principles, is extremely primitive. It allows virtually any conclusion to be arrived at without danger of refutation and it is incapable of dealing with institutions that have complex dynamics.

These theoretical limitations have long been understood by Marx’s followers. Lenin’s major contribution to Marxist theory, “Imperialism, the highest stage of capitalism”, written in 1916, was an attempt to reconcile the Marxist class model with the observed facts that the predicted divisions within classes had not broken down, instead competition between the international bourgeoisie had seen the mobilisation of their respective national proletariats in a great war, where they killed one another by the million. Other theorists such as Kautsky, Luxembourg and Gramsci attempted to elaborate the model by incorporating cultural factors and more subtleties into the treatment of the state. Marx himself painted a far more nuanced picture than that which has been transmitted and attempted to address many of the above limitations – such as the class nature of the state - in later works.

However, none of the attempted patches made much of a difference to the evolution of socialism, nor were they particularly successful on a theoretical level. In some cases, events proved them disastrously wrong: Lenin’s theory of imperialism predicted that capitalism was in its death throes in 1916. In most others, the theorists were able to identify significant factors that were outside the basic class model, but were never really able to successfully integrate them into a whole. There conclusions can be summed up as follows: the basic class model was still valid but other stuff was also important and the various factors might interact in complex ways. Not a whole lot of help in answering practical questions. In any case, such theoretical innovations made relatively little impact upon the broad socialist support base. The resilience of the class model owes much to its simplicity and its foundational nature – it was described on the first page of the Communist Manifesto, a page that has probably been read far more widely than any other page of political theory in history.

Not only does the class model provide an analytic framework through which one can understand society, it also provides an answer to the question of what needs to be done to move towards a better society. But there’s more to it's appeal than just that. Certainly, simplicity and a clear course of action are necessary requirements of any political model becoming widely adopted. However, the class model of social dynamics has something else going for it: for all of its limitations, it’s bloody good. It predicts and explains many observed features of modern capitalist society, features which are utterly mysterious when viewed through the liberal-democratic model. Indeed, properly constrained, it is an exceedingly powerful predictive model. This is the intellectual attraction of the far-left, it provides its adherents with an analytic framework which really does help them in understanding why things happen the way that they do. On the other hand, the limitations of the model are such that it turns out to be a very poor guide to action, while the primitive analytic methods that have been passed down make it very difficult to address these limitations.

 The second part of this article will look at the strengths and weaknesses of the basic class model of society and some of their implications when it comes to political activity.

Comments (12)

Josh Ocular

This was worth waiting for. I very much enjoyed the 3-stage model differentiating SD, RM, @ interpretations of transition to utopia. But I do wonder whether it give sufficient credit to Engels' "withering away of the state".

Roberthart buy xenical buy online lasix buy cheap inderal buy crixivan buy lexapro online buy deltasone online cheap tofranil buy singulair buy stromectol estrace buy buy cardura cheap ocuflox buy xenical online buy amoxil order prograf buy cheap amoxil order renova prandin buy buy combivir online trental buy buy plavix order stromectol cytoxan buy online order bactrim order xenical order renagel order celebrex buy seroquel buy estrace buy cheap geodon buy albenza online buy tegretol online buy rocaltrol online order clomid order advair buy combivir online cheap vibramycin order danocrine exelon buy buy online cipro buy cheap aventyl order topamax buy online vepesid hyzaar buy buy online trental buy online vibramycin nolvadex buy online buy robaxin online buy cheap parlodel cheap neurontin trental buy minocin buy online buy online norvasc amaryl buy online

Roberthart игровые автоматы работа москва игровые автоматы играть белатра азартные игры в общественных местах игромания азартные игры скачать сборник игровых автоматов торрент скачать программу мега джек карточная игра пьяница скачать игровые автоматы харьков 2012 кремлевская рулетка играть игровой автомат клубничка 2 флеш игры казино рулетка игровые автоматы елена казино игровые автоматы gaminator секреты играть игровые автоматы 777 слот игры онлайн бесплатно эмуляторы игровых аппаратов скачать resident играть играть азартные игры синонимы автоматы игровые вегас 777 фараон казино онлайн видео azartplay бумажные деньги для игры игровые автоматы сокровище пиратов онлайн игры онлайн игровые автоматы бесплатно интернет казино голден геймес вулкан игровые автоматы вход играть в игровые автоматы в кредит игровые автоматы новоматик катано панда печки автомат игровой автомат скалолаз бесплатно купить игровые автоматы в китае карточная игра король на даме crazy monkey java игры клубника игровые автоматы игровой автомат с шариком коллекционные карточные игры топ игровой автомат чукча играть бесплатно игровые автоматы на деньги андроид игры онлайн бесплатно игровые аппараты slots games слот аниме скачать бесплатно скачать игры для андроид слот казино чайна таун 36 онлайн настроить игровой автомат игровые автоматы вулкан бесплатновулкан играть в игровые автоматы 777 онлайн где надо зарабатывать деньги игры интернет казино видео слот алладин игровые автоматы алькатрас онлайн бесплатно азартные игры в интернете гаминаторы онлайн играть бесплатно русские азартные игры азартные игры андроид

Roberthart buy cheap diovan order altace cheap ceftin buy desyrel buy online plavix buy online xenical bystolic buy online cheap danocrine buy online ceftin buy online cardura buy cheap biaxin order micardis buy online zofran order altace aggrenox buy buy deltasone online urispas buy online cheap crixivan buy biaxin online biaxin buy online buy online tenormin order lamictal buy cheap crixivan buy xylocaine singulair buy order effexor bactrim buy online norvasc buy online buy online lamictal buy crixivan online order bactrim buy online urispas order compazine requip buy buy lithobid buy online danocrine tofranil buy online cheap tofranil order moduretic buy sporanox buy online cleocin order zithromax buy mestinon plavix buy online order pyridium buy cheap clozaril buy lithobid online advair buy order phoslo ceftin buy online buy exelon lithobid buy cheap tofranil buy xylocaine online

Roberthart buy cheap priligy buy online flagyl buy cheap renova oxytrol buy online crixivan buy buy plavix buy asacol buy online buspar buy stromectol duricef buy online buy duricef online buy anafranil online order flagyl buy sporanox buy lithobid order flagyl order aristocort duricef buy online estrace buy online cheap zyprexa cheap amoxil buy online evista cheap mestinon buy cheap noroxin cheap dostinex buy tofranil buy online propecia buy tofranil online zetia buy online order zetia buy cheap compazine buy mestinon online buy cheap renagel buy online sinequan buy online requip naprosyn buy glucophage buy buspar buy online naprosyn buy online order biaxin order minocin cheap cytoxan combivir buy buy propecia arava buy online order oxytrol cheap tegretol stromectol buy cheap adalat buy aristocort online order aventyl order celebrex buy cheap prograf

Roberthart lasix buy online mestinon buy flomax buy online buy estrace online buy cheap clozaril pyridium buy zetia buy buy vepesid buy cheap danocrine buy pyridium buy trental lexapro buy online buy online moduretic buy cheap albenza buy cheap priligy order sinequan order premarin aventyl buy buy zithromax cytoxan buy buy vibramycin buy cheap geodon buy cheap pyridium vibramycin buy online buy periactin order actoplus requip buy order dostinex buy cheap parlodel buy periactin buy online diflucan order tofranil buy online amoxil buy online moduretic bactrim buy buy cheap topamax hyzaar buy buy online maxalt buy online bactrim bactrim buy online sinequan buy buy pyridium alesse buy risperdal buy buy hytrin online cheap mobic buy cheap crixivan buy flagyl online cheap pyridium premarin buy online buy cheap boniva aggrenox buy online buy zofran buy trental online

Roberthart gratis casino bonus lulea casinon pa natete Choy Sun Doa spelautomat spelautomater flashback spelautomater Koi Fortune vip baccarat macau online spela spelautomat william hill casino Eskilstuna casinon pa natet svenska casino med bonus French Roulette Pro spelautomater Kramfors bra spel i mobilen free casino spel nordibet bonuskoodi slots casino bonus codes vegas casino dk spelautomater Time Machine casino guide ni no kuni betsson aktie forum casino Vasteras spelautomater Jonkoping moneybookers review spilleautomat Mega Fortune casino on net free download casino live dealers online nya spelautomater casino Pitea spelautomater Picnic Panic slots casino bonus spela slots med latsaspengar spelautomat sajt casino lucky31 spela casino pa skoj lets dance 2015 biljetter casino europa spelautomater Arabian Nights baby bingo svenska falkoping casinon pa natete flen casinon pa natete spel svenska som andrasprak roullette band basta casino sajten Hoganas casinon pa natet gratis spel till mobilen sony ericsson DoublePlay SuperBet spelautomat spela betsson casino pa ipad casino sundsvall meny casino pa natet svenska bonik casino halmstad vip baccarat squeeze android piggy bank 50 cent triple pocket holdem poker cherry casino lund

Roberthart basta natcasino online casino downloads free spelautomater Tivoli Bonanza casino live dealers online superman returns spel casino karlstadt casino valkenburg spela hjarter gratis amal casinon pa natete betsson poker app android betsafe casino bonus spilleautomat Burning Desire spilleautomat Gonzos Quest spelautomater lotteriinspektionen jackpot slots modded apk spilleautomat Tornadough casino Trollhattan casino or bonus utan insättning sverige online casino spelautomater Simsalabim punto banco online sverige casino lyrics svenska spel bingo live casino med free spins spilleautomat Octopuss Garden Punto Banco Mjolby casinon pa natet casinon 2015 casinoroom bonus roxy palace download freespins eu casino signup bonus code roulette spel free slots games for fun live blackjack dealer jackpotcitybingo norrkoping casinon pa natete iphone casino apps no deposit pai gow poker odds Harnosand casinon pa natet roulette casino youtube spela keno online blackjack spelling free casino spel gratis spela slots gratis skraplotter på nätet Steam Tower spelautomat Stickers spelautomat mr green casino erfahrung vinnarum casino mobil mr green black jack online Ronneby casinon pa natet basta mobilen just nu Trollhattan casinon pa natet

Roberthart casinofoorumi casino suomi24 lotto kierros 42 suomalaiset vedonlyöntisivustot starburst slots review peliautomaatit Orimattila grand casino mn erottajan kasino helsinki casino online lotto todennakoisyys roulette bot pro 3 viking lotto kierros 47 lauantai jokerin oikea rivi arcade ilmaiset pelit ja nettipelit jack hammer 2 slot review parhaat Suomi peliautomaattisivustot single deck blackjack house edge blackjack säännöt ray free casino money no deposit 2015 best online casino peliautomaatit Tampere pinkki pantteri pelit casino no deposit free spins red casino betsafe kilpailuttaa ruotsiksi suomalaiset rahapelit paf bingo säännöt lucky angler slots tuplapotti vinkit viking lotto 12 september comeon casino wiki suomen mestaruus yhteen vai erikseen video slots deposit bonus Shake It Up peliautomaatti viking loton numerot kierros 7 puhelinlaskulla rahaa tilille ilmainen casino bonus live blackjack card counting pajatso peli myytävänä peliautomaatti Jewel Box mega joker free download internet pelit kasino hedelmäpelit bonus pikapokeri flash evolution slot review tuplapotti flash eurokasino casino redstar dead or alive slot big win ray pelaamo helsinki quatro casino flash player viging lotto suomivegas casino lotto kierros 38/2015

Roberthart french roulette rules starburst braid ilmaisia nettipelejä arcade ilmaiset pelit perinteinen pasianssi paf bonuskoodi 2015 Hall of Gods peliautomaatti päivä kenon oikeat numerot Uusikaarlepyy nettikasinot kasino kuopio lotto kierros 44 tulokset texas holdem ilmaiseksi casino classic ray automaatti ruletti Lapua nettikasinot blackjack free download evolution slot cars jokerin oikea rivi voita rahaa ruletissa peliautomaatti Iron Man casino ray helsinki finland roulette bot pro suomenkieliset pelit Shake It Up peliautomaatti netticasino talletus puhelimella Santas Wild Ride peliautomaatti kasino Kauhava 50 pennin pajatso myydään ray rahapelit nordicbet bonus kasino Pyhajarvi casino nettipelit black jack black casinoeuro arvostelu ilmaista pelirahaa ilman talletusta peliautomaatti Stash of the Titans nettipokerin sm tulokset rock pokeri 16 nordicbet bonuskoodi vanhoille asiakkaille keno tulokset 16.9 mega fortune jackpot kulta jaska valtaus oikeat lottonumerot kierros 11 spin casino slots lotto oikeat rivit iphone casinos for us players suomen lottovoitot lotto kierros 32/12 loton oikeat numerot kierros 42 casino room bonus code arabia kasino casino winner mobile ilmainen pelikone hyviä pelejä puhelimeen kilpailuttaa englanniksi

Roberthart lucky angler slot live blackjack 21 lottorivi 17.10 lotto tulokset 2015 pelikone muut pelit arpakone sports bar casino melbourne ray kuluttaja asiakaspalvelu bingo generator lottonumerot 44 loton arvonta 30.11 vikinglotto sendetid lasten online peleja netticasino bonus excalibur slot machines cherry casino affiliates roulette yhtye 888 casino download perjantain jokerin tulokset ilmainen bonus ilman talletusta pontoon vs blackjack odds kaikki internet kasinot paras pokerihuone 2015 casino vaasa Mikkeli nettikasinot peliautomaatti Dynasty loton voittonumerot 2015 vaaleanpunainen pantteri peliautomaatti bonus ilman talletusta ilmaista pelirahaa ilman talletusta paf spade poker jackpot 6000 za darmo sefcu mobile banking roulette online free ladbrokes ilmaisia rahapeleja netissa keno numero internet casino software come on casino lotto voitonjako kierros 35 keno kunkku kerroin parhaat pokeripelit casinoeuro 20 free spins lottorivi 17.10 casinoroom 20 free spins hedelma peli veikkaus lottonumerot kierros 23 jack hammer slots lottorivi kierros 23/2015 pai gow poker odds lotto kierros 28 oikea rivi yksikatinen rosvo jokeripokeri kadet lucky angler slot ilmaista rahaa kasinolle ilman talletusta

Add new comment